Saturday, March 9, 2013

Harry Potter Alternate Endings


My dream last night had alternate endings for the Harry Potter series.  I have never read the books, and I only saw two of the movies—one that I was delighted and overjoyed at seeing, the other that I despised so much, I had no interest in seeing the rest.   And no, I won’t say which was which. 

  
In my dream it was nearing midnight, and Harry, Hermione, and Ron had fled to an elevator at the top of a dark castle.  There, they awaited the final battle with ultimate evil—tense, wordless, with no real hope of victory. 

They were joined by the twins, who suddenly entered the elevator, and who had become powerful wizards in their own right.  This cheered the original trio, improving their odds.  One of the twins took some time to lean over to Hermione and ask if she was all right, obviously concerned she might have been physically injured.  That done, the five of them waited in silence for the showdown with ultimate evil. 

My dream skipped the final battle. 

It now went to one of two alternate endings.  In the Potter series, Harry and his friends are going to their academy in real time, and the people who know them are aware they are growing up.  But in my dream they were spending time in a realm where time passes differently, much as in the old fairy stories where people spend time in Faerie and come back startled at the difference in time. 

In the first alternate ending, Harry, Hermione, and Ron have reverted to their ages at the start of the series.  They are running across an open-air stone structure, high above a grassy field and with a body of water in the distance.  They are concerned about getting back to our realm, and Hermione leads the way.  She remembers they have to crawl through a semicircular opening in the low stone wall on the edge of the structure—obviously designed to allow water to drain out.  Hermione is the first one through, followed by the two boys. 

They drop down to the field without injury, then look back up at the stone structure.  Drops fall on their faces from the opening, and they realize in disgust that the drops are sewage. 

The three of them turn and run through the field with great difficulty because of their small size and the high grass, often having to hop as they run.  They wonder how much time has passed here, and whether their families have been looking for them. 

This part of the dream ended.  Obviously, this is similar to the end of C.S. Lewis’ The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, where the four children come out of the wardrobe at their original ages. 

photo by Zaheer12a

Now the dream turned to the other alternate ending.  The trio return to our realm with their ages intact, but hardly any time has passed here.  Hermione returns to a job she had, taking in people’s wash.  With a basket of laundry tucked under one arm, she approaches an elderly woman sitting on some outside steps at night. 

Hermione is not sure how many hours have passed, or if it is the same day.  Trying to act normal, she hands a large ticket back to the elderly woman, to see if the laundry is due.  (I know the customer hands the ticked to the launderer, but this is how my dream went.) 

The elderly woman hands the ticket back, saying, “It’s not due.”  Then she looks Hermione up and down.  Finally, she says, “Child, why is your face is so wan?  Why don’t you come inside?” 

Hermione is puzzled at the elderly woman’s refusal to acknowledge reality:  Hermione is not only taller, but she has gone from being a child to being a woman. But she smells the scent of hot soup coming from the woman’s apartment, and she relaxes and agrees to go inside. 

photo by John Griffiths

Meanwhile, Ron is sitting in the middle of a dark living room.  He is staring at a framed photograph in his hands of himself, taken at the start of his adventures.  The picture shows him as a young child.  Done with his contemplation, he looks up and says to his parents (who are outside the range of my dream), “Obviously, I’m older.”  This is the revelation moment, after his parents have accepted him back but have awkwardly not shown any notice of the change in him.  The dream shifts. 

photo by DavidDjJohnson  

Harry is standing in a grocery store at night.  He is startled to find the cheese crackers he was looking for—the boxes are on hangers which can be swung back and forth, the way movie posters used to be displayed in music stores.  He is obviously not used to seeing crackers displayed like this and wonders at the differences brought by the passage of years.  (This contradicts the premise that practically no time has passed in our realm, but that is the nature of dreams.) 

Harry’s mother comes walking down an aisle towards him, muttering out loud the items they need to buy.  (Yes, I know Harry is an orphan.  It’s a dream.)  She comes up to him without looking at him, still talking. 

He interrupts her.  “Look at me.” 

She does.  What she has been avoiding after accepting him back and going to the store with him becomes undeniable as they stare each other in the eyes:  Harry has grown up. 

Harry continues to stare at her, wondering what will come of this.  The dream ends. 

That second ending was more the Rip Van Winkle sort of ending, but with people oddly wanting to avoid the unexplainable aging of the three former children. 

This is not fan fiction.  The dream really happened, so in a way it’s a form of non-fiction.  It may seem suspiciously literary and detailed, but I have added nothing to it.  All the scenes were dark, except for the ending where they are running across the stone structure and the grassy field, which was in filtered sunlight—presumably that part of my dream was lit so I could see the action.  Also, The grown version of Harry Potter did not look like Daniel Radcliffe.  He looked like Stephen Kreiger, who used to hold the world record for the longest paper airplane throw.  See my entry on him. 

If you want to have dreams this literary and this detailed, I suggest you read and write a lot.  

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I love the vividness of your dreams, Mark, and how well the tone of them matches the tone of the movies: dark, quirky, and held together through the relationships of the young people. I was disappointed that you did not include an interpretation of the dream. What have you been reading lately? What has been going on in your life? When was the last time you saw Stephen K? And, yes, I would like to know which of the Potter movies you found so revolting.

S

Mark Murata said...

I have no interpretation: as a wannabe writer, I think about story structure a lot. I have not seen Stephen in a long time—since I didn’t see the concluding movies of the series, I didn’t really see how Daniel Radcliffe had grown up in his role, so Stephen filled the role of a slim, dark-haired, serious young man. And no, I won’t say which movie I found so revolting, since that would be telling.

Damyanti said...

Why do I never have dreams as detailed and memorable as this? I envy you.

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...